Someone Else

Robert Moir writes about Operating Systems, Computer Security and Virtualisation.

Open Letter to Microsoft

And the hits just keep coming on the MVP for adware and his award.

Having read my letter of thanks from Microsoft and realised that I might be considered for award again in the future, I have today sent this letter to my former contact at Microsoft. 

Open Letter to Microsoft

Many thanks for your note on the 1 Oct 06 telling me that I was not going to be renewed in the MVP program this year. I certainly appreciate that this is Microsoft's decision to make, and as such I have no problem with that. It's been a great 8 years and I've enjoyed working with you and all the other leads.

I am concerned to note that my contributions to the community are rated below those of someone who peddles spyware & adware to your customers, as the author of Messenger Plus, known as Patchou, has been newly awarded this year. You may or may not be aware that Messenger Plus has a long history of installing spyware/adware alongside itself, exposing minors to adult content, etc.

I'm unsure whether this is a horrible mistake on Microsoft's part, or an interesting new direction for Microsoft and its trustworthy computing initiative, but I am actually glad you chose not to renew me this year as that has saved me the trouble of having to turn down the chance to be held in the same regard as that person.

I would like to formally ask you to ensure that I am NOT considered for any future MVP awards while this individual is part of the scheme. Please don't take this the wrong way, but I'm doing this to help you. Having insulted me once by implying my contribution to the community is worth less than that of a spyware peddler, I want to save both of us some upset in the future if you ever found cause to inform me that my contribution to the community has once again risen to a level where you now consider me to be as useful as a spyware peddler.

Comments

mark said:

Seems like your wish was granted Robert!

# October 11, 2006 10:18 AM

Robert Moir said:

It does, Mark. I guess it's a shame that things were handled badly to start with, but MS have done their best to put it right.

Of course, hordes of MsgPlus users are now equally disgusted that he's lost his award. And rightly so; not that i've changed my mind from my original opinion, but clearly it is humiliating for Patchou to gain then lose the award. No-one really 'won' I guess.

It would have been better for everyone if the supposedly painstaking MVP selection process included running a candidate's software through Microsoft's own malware scanners, or maybe just using google a bit.

# October 11, 2006 11:51 AM